Because your vote counts

Is a Historic Shift in Power Near?

Is a Historic Shift in Power Near?

​

The Tectonic Shift.

The Democratic Party has a realistic chance to make major gains in both the House and Senate, including, incredibly, in the 25 red states that Donald Trump carried in three successive elections. In a recent article, the New York Times featured quotes from Republican operatives: “’It’s a five-alarm fire.’ A ‘slow moving car crash.’ Republicans are ‘hemorrhaging’ and ‘should brace for losing everything.'”

This Republican vulnerability certainly exists in the “fair fight” swing districts, in which Republican House incumbents, many of whom are able politicians adept at political survival, have seen their re-election contests moved by impartial analysts like Cook and Sabato from “Lean Republican” to “Toss-Up.” But that shift might be expected in an ordinary off-year election in which an incumbent Republican president has lost popularity.

It is also happening, however, in districts gerrymandered this year at Trump’s direction. In these districts, Democratic incumbents regarded earlier this year as facing certain defeat and new Democratic candidates are holding their own. Some have moved into the Toss-Up category. 

And most astonishing, in various ruby red states, Democratic and Democratic-supported independent Senate candidates are either leading in impartial polls or are running even with Republicans. That is the case, for example, in Texas and Kansas, in which Democratic Senators were last elected in 1988 and 1932, respectively. This gives us hope. 

However, nothing is certain. Republicans are cornered and can be expected to spend unprecedented amounts of money and use the dirtiest of campaign tactics in the last weeks of the campaign, not to speak of Trump seeking to interfere with the election. Democratic supporters need to fight back with our money and with our efforts to get out and protect the vote. We have a chance to produce a historic shift in power at a critical time in our country’s history. P4D believes that our realistic objective should be to achieve a blue wave big enough for Democrats to overcome any “October surprise” (Trump’s words) that the President and his allies might attempt.

In this email we highlight a Toss-Up swing district in New York, and two gerrymandered districts in Florida in which the Democratic candidates, one an incumbent and the other a new candidate, now have a good chance to win. Finally, we discuss the Kansas Senate race, in which a good Democratic candidate has a chance to make political history. 

Before you read this, here is an idea:

Trump is giving each person on traditional Medicare $90 to help offset premium payments. If you are in a position to do so, consider contributing it to one of these candidates or another of your choosing.

New York—17th District

New York’s 17th congressional district, located north of New York City, encompasses much of the lower Hudson River valley.  It’s widely considered a swing district, and it’s one of very few districts in the country that voted for Kamala Harris and elected a Republican to the House in 2024.  

 

Even though it’s viewed as a swing district, the current incumbent, Mike Lawler, was the first Republican to win the seat since 1986 when he won in a 2022 upset.  His Democratic opponent, Cait Conley, is a West Point grad and an army veteran who served at the National Security Council and the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency in Joe Biden’s White House. 

In this year when anti-Trump forces appear to be in a strong position, Lawler is trying to define himself as a bipartisan, pragmatic leader, although Trump campaigned for him at a rally in May, and he has been a reliable supporter of Trump in the House.  Conley, like most Democrats in tight districts, is running on cost of living and affordability issues.  She’s also talking about corruption in Washington and her military service.

 

The major campaign observers, including Cook and Sabato, all rank the race a Toss-Up.  A late-September poll showed Conley up by 2 points.

DONATE

Florida—14th District

This is a heavily gerrymandered district, thanks to the mid-cycle Republican re-districting earlier this year. Under the old boundaries, Harris won this district in 2024 53.3% to 45.6%. Under the new boundaries, Trump won the district 54.7% to 44.2%, a 9-point swing.

Another notable feature of this race is that there are 5 candidates. In addition to incumbent Democrat Kathy Castor and Republican challenger Mike Beltran, there are a Libertarian and two write-in candidates with no party affiliation. Practically, however, this is a race between Castor and Beltran.

This had been a safe Democratic district until the re-districting earlier this year, which initially caused most pundits to rate this race Lean Republican. But that has shifted over the succeeding months, with Cook Political Report, Inside Elections, and Sabato’s Crystal Ball all changing their rating to Toss-Up, and with Decision Desk calling it Lean Democratic. Cook switched from Lean Republican to Toss-Up on August 25, while Sabato made the same switch earlier, on July 30.

Castor was first elected to Congress in 2006, representing Florida’s 11th District. In 2012, following re-districting, she ran in the 14th District and has represented this district since. As an example of her legislative priorities and effectiveness, Castor, as chair of the House Select Committee on the Climate Crisis, produced a broad climate action framework that shaped subsequent Democratic climate legislation. Castor says that her number one priority now is to provide better-paying jobs for the Tampa Bay region (which this district covers). She touts her success in bringing good-paying job opportunities to the region.

 

Beltran served in the Florida House from 2018 to 2024. He is running onlowering government spending, balancing the federal budget, and reducing the cost of living. He says he is “aligned with President Trump’s agenda.” Trump has endorsed him, and he endorsed Trump in 2024.

DONATE

Florida – 22nd District

This race has no incumbent because the incumbent representative (Lois Frankel) is running for re-election in District 23, to which much of former District 22 was moved in this year’s re-districting. New 

District 22 is red, voting for Trump in 2024 55% to 44%, although it voted for Biden in 2020. Pia Dandiya (D) is running against Casey Askar (R).

Three outlets (Decision Desk, Inside Elections, and Sabato’s Crystal Ball) rate this race Lean Republican. Cook Political Report did too, until September 29, when it switched to a Toss-Up rating. There are no recent polls and no high-quality polls. The most recent poll, in late August, had a Democratic sponsor and showed Dandiya up 2 points.

Dandiya earned a B.A. in government from Harvard. She then taught middle and high school until she became a high school principal at age 28. Then she was selected as a White House Fellow and served in that capacity at the Domestic Policy Council and the Department of Education in both Democratic and Republican administrations. She eventually switched to the private sector, working for Apple as a strategic initiatives manager. Now she is campaigning for Congress, first and foremost, on reducing the cost of living, but also on enacting government reforms such as banning members of Congress from trading individual stocks.

Her Republican opponent, Casey Askar, is President of Askar Brands, which includes various pizza restaurants and other food and beverage companies. He also has invested in the automotive and energy industries and in commercial real estate. Like his opponent, he is campaigning on reducing the cost of living. He wants to repeal Obamacare and replace it with something that, he says, “works for all Americans.”

DONATE

Kansas Senate

 

You can hear Dorothy now, “I don’t think we’re in Kansas anymore.”  Why? Because a big political tornado named “Affordability” has touched down and is wreaking havoc on Republican chances of holding a Senate seat. Kansas has not elected a Democratic senator since 1932. The Wizard of Oz was released in 1939. 

Kansas is feeling the brunt of Trump policies. Farmers are hurt by the price of gasoline and diesel due to the Iran war. Immigration policy has choked off a key source of workers in the cattle industry. Cattle farmers also are being hurt by reduced tariffs on beef imports. Democrat Rev. Adam Hamilton, the pastor of the largest Methodist church in the country, is trying to unseat first term Republican Roger Marshall. He bills himself as a centrist who wants to end the Iran war, fix tariffs, and regulate data centers. Two former Republican governors in Kansas support him. 

The New York Times reported that Rogers, a former ROB-GYN, filed suit for non-payment against 700 patients and was charging them 18% interest. Most of these patients lived in Barton County, a rural area with above-average uninsured and poverty rates. Marshall’s backing of Donald Trump has become an albatross as 55% of Kansans disapprove of Trump according to the Times. 

Sabato’s Crystal Ball has moved this race from Likely Republican to Lean Republican, and the Cook Report in early October shifted it to Toss-Up. The most recent New York Times/Sienna Poll shows each candidate with 45%. Solid evidence of GOP worries emerged on October 2 as Republicans stopped spending money in the North Carolina Senate race, in essence conceding to Democrat Roy Cooper. They have started spending the money instead in Kansas. 

In the end, Dorothy wakes up, and she and Toto are home in Kansas. Hopefully, Kansans are waking up, and Marshall will be returned home as well. For real.

 

​

The Tectonic Shift

The Democratic Party has a realistic chance to make major gains in both the House and Senate, including, incredibly, in the 25 red states that Donald Trump carried in three successive elections. In a recent article, the New York Times featured quotes from Republican operatives: “’It’s a five-alarm fire.’ A ‘slow moving car crash.’ Republicans are ‘hemorrhaging’ and ‘should brace for losing everything.‘”

 

This Republican vulnerability certainly exists in the “fair fight” swing districts, in which Republican House incumbents, many of whom are able politicians adept at political survival, have seen their re-election contests moved by impartial analysts like Cook and Sabato from “Lean Republican” to “Toss-Up.” But that shift might be expected in an ordinary off-year election in which an incumbent Republican president has lost popularity.

 

It is also happening, however, in districts gerrymandered this year at Trump’s direction. In these districts, Democratic incumbents regarded earlier this year as facing certain defeat and new Democratic candidates are holding their own. Some have moved into the Toss-Up category. 

 

And most astonishing, in various ruby red states, Democratic and Democratic-supported independent Senate candidates are either leading in impartial polls or are running even with Republicans. That is the case, for example, in Texas and Kansas, in which Democratic Senators were last elected in 1988 and 1932, respectively. This gives us hope. 

 

However, nothing is certain. Republicans are cornered and can be expected to spend unprecedented amounts of money and use the dirtiest of campaign tactics in the last weeks of the campaign, not to speak of Trump seeking to interfere with the election. Democratic supporters need to fight back with our money and with our efforts to get out and protect the vote. We have a chance to produce a historic shift in power at a critical time in our country’s history. P4D believes that our realistic objective should be to achieve a blue wave big enough for Democrats to overcome any “October surprise” (Trump’s words) that the President and his allies might attempt.

 

In this email we highlight a Toss-Up swing district in New York, and two gerrymandered districts in Florida in which the Democratic candidates, one an incumbent and the other a new candidate, now have a good chance to win. Finally, we discuss the Kansas Senate race, in which a good Democratic candidate has a chance to make political history. 

 

Before you read this, here is an idea:

 

Trump is giving each person on traditional Medicare $90 to help offset premium payments. If you are in a position to do so, consider contributing it to one of these candidates or another of your choosing.

New York—17th District

 

New York’s 17th congressional district, located north of New York City, encompasses much of the lower Hudson River valley.  It’s widely considered a swing district, and it’s one of very few districts in the country that voted for Kamala Harris and elected a Republican to the House in 2024.  

 

Even though it’s viewed as a swing district, the current incumbent, Mike Lawler, was the first Republican to win the seat since 1986 when he won in a 2022 upset.  His Democratic opponent, Cait Conley, is a West Point grad and an army veteran who served at the National Security Council and the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency in Joe Biden’s White House. 

 

In this year when anti-Trump forces appear to be in a strong position, Lawler is trying to define himself as a bipartisan, pragmatic leader, although Trump campaigned for him at a rally in May, and he has been a reliable supporter of Trump in the House.  Conley, like most Democrats in tight districts, is running on cost of living and affordability issues.  She’s also talking about corruption in Washington and her military service.

  

The major campaign observers, including Cook and Sabato, all rank the race a Toss-Up.  A late-September poll showed Conley up by 2 points.

DONATE

Florida—14th District

 

This is a heavily gerrymandered district, thanks to the mid-cycle Republican re-districting earlier this year. Under the old boundaries, Harris won this district in 2024 53.3% to 45.6%. Under the new boundaries, Trump won the district 54.7% to 44.2%, a 9-point swing.

 

Another notable feature of this race is that there are 5 candidates. In addition to incumbent Democrat Kathy Castor and Republican challenger Mike Beltran, there are a Libertarian and two write-in candidates with no party affiliation. Practically, however, this is a race between Castor and Beltran.

 

This had been a safe Democratic district until the re-districting earlier this year, which initially caused most pundits to rate this race Lean Republican. But that has shifted over the succeeding months, with Cook Political Report, Inside Elections, and Sabato’s Crystal Ball all changing their rating to Toss-Up, and with Decision Desk calling it Lean Democratic. Cook switched from Lean Republican to Toss-Up on August 25, while Sabato made the same switch earlier, on July 30.

 

Castor was first elected to Congress in 2006, representing Florida’s 11th District. In 2012, following re-districting, she ran in the 14th District and has represented this district since. As an example of her legislative priorities and effectiveness, Castor, as chair of the House Select Committee on the Climate Crisis, produced a broad climate action framework that shaped subsequent Democratic climate legislation. Castor says that her number one priority now is to provide better-paying jobs for the Tampa Bay region (which this district covers). She touts her success in bringing good-paying job opportunities to the region.

Beltran served in the Florida House from 2018 to 2024. He is running onlowering government spending, balancing the federal budget, and reducing the cost of living. He says he is “aligned with President Trump’s agenda.” Trump has endorsed him, and he endorsed Trump in 2024.

DONATE

Florida – 22nd District

 

This race has no incumbent because the incumbent representative (Lois Frankel) is running for re-election in District 23, to which much of former District 22 was moved in this year’s re-districting. New 

District 22 is red, voting for Trump in 2024 55% to 44%, although it voted for Biden in 2020. Pia Dandiya (D) is running against Casey Askar (R).

 

Three outlets (Decision Desk, Inside Elections, and Sabato’s Crystal Ball) rate this race Lean Republican. Cook Political Report did too, until September 29, when it switched to a Toss-Up rating. There are no recent polls and no high-quality polls. The most recent poll, in late August, had a Democratic sponsor and showed Dandiya up 2 points.

Dandiya earned a B.A. in government from Harvard. She then taught middle and high school until she became a high school principal at age 28. Then she was selected as a White House Fellow and served in that capacity at the Domestic Policy Council and the Department of Education in both Democratic and Republican administrations. She eventually switched to the private sector, working for Apple as a strategic initiatives manager. Now she is campaigning for Congress, first and foremost, on reducing the cost of living, but also on enacting government reforms such as banning members of Congress from trading individual stocks.

 

Her Republican opponent, Casey Askar, is President of Askar Brands, which includes various pizza restaurants and other food and beverage companies. He also has invested in the automotive and energy industries and in commercial real estate. Like his opponent, he is campaigning on reducing the cost of living. He wants to repeal Obamacare and replace it with something that, he says, “works for all Americans.”

DONATE

Kansas Senate

You can hear Dorothy now, “I don’t think we’re in Kansas anymore.”  Why? Because a big political tornado named “Affordability” has touched down and is wreaking havoc on Republican chances of holding a Senate seat. Kansas has not elected a Democratic senator since 1932. The Wizard of Oz was released in 1939. 

 

Kansas is feeling the brunt of Trump policies. Farmers are hurt by the price of gasoline and diesel due to the Iran war. Immigration policy has choked off a key source of workers in the cattle industry. Cattle farmers also are being hurt by reduced tariffs on beef imports. Democrat Rev. Adam Hamilton, the pastor of the largest Methodist church in the country, is trying to unseat first term Republican Roger Marshall. He bills himself as a centrist who wants to end the Iran war, fix tariffs, and regulate data centers. Two former Republican governors in Kansas support him. 

 

The New York Times reported that Rogers, a former ROB-GYN, filed suit for non-payment against 700 patients and was charging them 18% interest. Most of these patients lived in Barton County, a rural area with above-average uninsured and poverty rates. Marshall’s backing of Donald Trump has become an albatross as 55% of Kansans disapprove of Trump according to the Times. 

 

Sabato’s Crystal Ball has moved this race from Likely Republican to Lean Republican, and the Cook Report in early October shifted it to Toss-Up. The most recent New York Times/Sienna Poll shows each candidate with 45%. Solid evidence of GOP worries emerged on October 2 as Republicans stopped spending money in the North Carolina Senate race, in essence conceding to Democrat Roy Cooper. They have started spending the money instead in Kansas. 

In the end, Dorothy wakes up, and she and Toto are home in Kansas. Hopefully, Kansans are waking up, and Marshall will be returned home as well. For real.

Top